Some links on our site may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Published July 2026 · Updated July 2026
Here’s the short answer: for most people hiking maintained trails on weekends, the Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX is the day hiking boot to buy first — a GORE-TEX membrane, a Vibram TC5+ outsole, and a genuinely lightweight build that’s been tested on terrain as demanding as Kilimanjaro, according to REI’s own hands-on review. It isn’t the cheapest boot here, and it isn’t the one built to survive a decade of hard use — that’s a different boot, further down. The six questions below are the ones that actually decide which of these six real, currently-sold boots belongs in your closet.
At a Glance: Six Hiking Boots, Sorted by the Question That Matters
| Boot | Answers the question | Price | Weight (men’s) | Waterproofing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX | “Which one should I just buy?” | $185 | 1 lb 12.2 oz | GORE-TEX |
| KEEN Hightrail Mid Waterproof | “What’s the cheapest boot that still holds up?” | $160 | 1 lb 13.3 oz | KEEN.DRY membrane |
| Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid GTX | “I want the lightest boot that’s still a boot” | $190 | 1 lb 15 oz | GORE-TEX |
| Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX | “I want one pair for the next decade” | $249.95 | 2 lb 4 oz | GORE-TEX 2-layer |
| Oboz Sawtooth X Mid Waterproof | “My ankles need real support” | $200 | 2 lb 6.8 oz | B-DRY membrane |
| HOKA Mafate Hike | “My feet hurt by mile six” | $200 | 1 lb 10.2 oz | Water-resistant only |
Jump to a section:
- Which boot should you just buy if you don’t want to think about it?
- What’s the cheapest boot that still holds up on real trail?
- Which boot is lightest without stopping being a boot?
- Which boot is built to survive a decade, not a season?
- Which boot gives your ankles the most real support?
- Which boot solves sore feet by mile six?
- Our Original Data: Cost Per 100 Miles, and When Resoling Beats Replacing
- How We Researched These Picks
- What Actually Matters When You’re Buying One
- Frequently Asked Questions
How We Picked Six Boots Out of a Genuinely Crowded Category
Dozens of hiking boots launch every year, and most buyer’s guides respond by listing fourteen of them with barely any differentiation. We did the opposite: we picked one clear question a real hiker actually asks — “which one should I just buy,” “what’s the cheapest one that holds up,” “my ankles need support” — and matched exactly one well-reviewed, currently-sold boot to each. If none of these six questions is yours, the buying-considerations section further down will help you figure out which one actually is.
Which Boot Should You Just Buy If You Don’t Want to Think About It?
The Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX is REI’s own Editors’ Choice pick in the moderate-terrain category, and for good reason: it pairs a GORE-TEX waterproof membrane with a Vibram TC5+ outsole and weighs a genuinely light 1 lb 12.2 oz per boot (men’s), according to REI’s published spec sheet. REI’s own testers wore the Moab Speed 2 on Kilimanjaro and came away impressed with its combination of low weight and real durability — not a common pairing in this category. It’s priced at $185.

Standout feature: it’s one of the few boots in this guide that reviewers describe as both lightweight and durable enough for genuinely rough, multi-day terrain, rather than making you choose one or the other.
Pros
- GORE-TEX waterproofing with a genuinely breathable build
- Vibram TC5+ outsole grips wet rock and loose trail alike
- Field-tested on demanding terrain, not just a lab treadmill
Cons
- One REI tester reported toe bruising on steep, sustained descents
- Mid-pack price for what’s ultimately a mid-weight boot
- Not the pick if you specifically need maximum ankle support
Best for: the day hiker who wants one boot that handles maintained trails, occasional scrambles, and everything in between without a lot of research.
What’s the Cheapest Boot That Still Holds Up on Real Trail?
The KEEN Hightrail Mid Waterproof is REI’s named budget pick in its hiking boot roundup, priced at $160 — the lowest of any boot in this guide — while still using KEEN’s own KEEN.DRY waterproof and breathable membrane and a high-rebound foam midsole. It weighs 1 lb 13.3 oz per boot (men’s), per REI’s spec sheet, putting it right in the middle of the pack on weight despite being the cheapest option here.
Standout feature: REI specifically calls out its versatility for “trail and town” wear — a genuine two-for-one if you don’t want a boot that only makes sense on a marked trailhead.
Pros
- Lowest price of any boot in this guide
- KEEN.DRY waterproofing with genuine all-day breathability
- Styled to double as an everyday shoe, not just trail-only footwear
Cons
- Doesn’t offer the rugged, multi-year durability of the Danner further down this guide
- Less ankle support than the Oboz Sawtooth X below
- No standout weakness noted, but it also doesn’t lead any single category
Best for: new hikers who don’t want to spend $200-plus to find out whether they actually like day hiking, and anyone who wants one boot for both the trail and the trailhead parking lot.
Which Boot Is Lightest Without Stopping Being a Boot?
The Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid GORE-TEX is GearJunkie’s named “Best Lightweight” pick, weighing 1 lb 15.5 oz per its own testing — genuinely light for a mid-height boot with full GORE-TEX waterproofing. GearJunkie’s review specifically praised its short break-in period and responsive midsole, calling it ideal for “day hikers and light backpackers,” and priced it at $190.
Standout feature: the short break-in period. Several boots in this guide need a few hikes to soften up; GearJunkie found this one comfortable close to out of the box.
Pros
- One of the lightest true boots in this guide
- Short break-in period, per GearJunkie’s hands-on testing
- Excellent traction on wet and slick terrain, per REI’s separate review of the same model
Cons
- GearJunkie notes less support for steep side-hilling than heavier boots
- REI flags a plush tongue that can limit a truly tight collar fit
- Not the pick for loaded overnight packs
Best for: day hikers and light backpackers who feel every extra ounce by mile eight and don’t want to trade that for a flimsy shoe.
Which Boot Is Built to Survive a Decade, Not a Season?
The Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX is the only boot in this guide built from full-grain leather with a GORE-TEX 2-layer waterproof/breathable laminate and a Vibram Megagrip outsole, per REI’s spec sheet — and, more importantly, it’s the only one Danner will resole for you once the outsole wears out. Danner’s own recrafting program lists a resole service at $100–$140 and a full rebuild (new outsole, midsole, insole, and hardware repair) at $280, according to Danner’s official recrafting page. It’s priced at $249.95 new and weighs 2 lb 4 oz per boot (men’s) — the heaviest boot in this guide.
Standout feature: resoleability. Every other boot here is a disposable, glued-construction product — wear out the outsole and you buy a new pair. The Mountain 600 Leaf is the one boot in this lineup designed to outlive its first outsole.
Pros
- Full-grain leather upper and Vibram Megagrip traction, per REI’s spec sheet
- Resoleable through Danner’s own recrafting program, unlike every other pick here
- REI’s review notes it’s comfortable close to out of the box despite the leather build
Cons
- Heaviest boot in this guide at 2 lb 4 oz per boot
- Highest upfront price of the six
- Overkill if you hike three times a year on flat, maintained trail
Best for: hikers who go through a pair of boots every year or two and would rather pay more once, resole twice, and stop buying new boots altogether. See the cost math below for exactly when that trade-off pays off.
Which Boot Gives Your Ankles the Most Real Support?
The Oboz Sawtooth X Mid Waterproof uses Oboz’s own B-DRY waterproof and breathable membrane and is built with what REI’s review describes as firm ankle support and adaptive cushioning aimed at longer days on trail. It weighs 2 lb 0.6 oz (women’s) to 2 lb 6.8 oz (men’s), per REI’s spec sheet, and is priced at $200.
Standout feature: the firmness of the ankle collar and midsole together, which REI’s testers specifically credited for confidence on uneven, rocky terrain where a softer boot lets your ankle roll.
Pros
- Firm ankle support built for longer, rougher days
- B-DRY waterproof membrane, per Oboz’s own spec sheet
- Adaptive cushioning holds up over sustained mileage, per REI’s review
Cons
- REI’s review flags a narrow toe box that can feel constricting on longer hikes
- Second-heaviest boot in this guide
- Not the pick for anyone who wants a wide toe box
Best for: hikers with a history of rolled ankles, or anyone regularly on loose, rocky, off-camber trail where lateral support matters more than a roomy toe box.
Which Boot Solves Sore Feet by Mile Six?
The HOKA Mafate Hike brings HOKA’s maximalist trail-running cushioning into a mid-height boot shape, weighing just 1 lb 6.68 oz (women’s) to 1 lb 10.2 oz (men’s) — the lightest boot in this entire guide, per REI’s spec sheet. REI’s review describes it as street-to-trail versatile with no break-in required, and prices it at $200. The one honest catch: it’s rated water-resistant, not fully waterproof, unlike every other boot in this guide.
Standout feature: the cushioning stack. If the other five boots in this guide are built around traction and support, the Mafate Hike is built around shock absorption first — a genuinely different priority.
Pros
- Lightest boot in this guide by a meaningful margin
- Maximum cushioning reduces foot fatigue on long days, per REI’s testing
- No break-in period needed, per REI’s review
Cons
- Water-resistant only — not rated for water crossings or sustained heavy rain, per REI
- Softer cushioning trades off some ground-feel and precision on technical terrain
- Dealbreaker if you regularly hike in genuinely wet conditions
Best for: hikers whose limiting factor is sore feet and joints rather than wet weather — long, mostly-dry day hikes where cushioning matters more than a fully sealed membrane.
Our Original Data: Cost Per 100 Miles, and When Resoling Beats Replacing
None of these six product pages tell you what a boot actually costs per mile of trail, so we built that number ourselves. According to Advnture’s guide to hiking boot lifespan, boot brands typically state their boots should last between 500 and 1,000 miles under normal use. We used the 750-mile midpoint of that range as a single, consistent assumption across all six boots, then divided each boot’s price by 7.5 to get a cost per 100 miles. This is our own calculation, not a manufacturer claim, and actual mileage will vary with terrain, pack weight, and how well you maintain a boot.
| Boot | Price | Assumed lifespan | Cost per 100 miles |
|---|---|---|---|
| KEEN Hightrail Mid Waterproof | $160 | 750 mi | $21.33 |
| Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX | $185 | 750 mi | $24.67 |
| Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid GTX | $190 | 750 mi | $25.33 |
| Oboz Sawtooth X Mid Waterproof | $200 | 750 mi | $26.67 |
| HOKA Mafate Hike | $200 | 750 mi | $26.67 |
| Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX (first 750 mi, no resole) | $249.95 | 750 mi | $33.33 |
On the first 750 miles alone, the Danner is the most expensive boot here per mile, exactly as its higher price tag suggests. But the Danner is also the only boot in this guide that Danner will resole rather than force you to replace. Add a second 750-mile life cycle using Danner’s own $100–$140 resole price (we used the $120 midpoint), and the math changes:
| Boot path | Total cost | Total miles | Cost per 100 miles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX: buy once, resole once | $249.95 + $120 = $369.95 | 1,500 mi | $24.66 |
| Any non-resoleable boot: buy twice to cover the same distance | 2 × original price | 1,500 mi | Same as the single-pair rate above |
Once you factor in a single resole, the Danner’s cost per 100 miles drops to $24.66 — cheaper than the Salomon, Oboz, and HOKA, and nearly identical to the Merrell, over the same 1,500 miles of trail. The KEEN still wins on pure price per mile even after a Danner resole, but the KEEN isn’t built to be resoled at all, so its 750-mile figure is the only number it will ever post — buy a second pair at full price and its long-run rate stays flat at $21.33 per 100 miles, while every non-resoleable boot in this table follows the same pattern. The takeaway: resoleability doesn’t make the Danner the cheapest boot here, but it does close most of the price gap with boots that cost $50–$90 less new, once you’re honest about what a second pair actually costs.
How We Researched These Picks
We did not physically test these six boots ourselves. This guide was built by cross-referencing hands-on testing and spec sheets published by REI’s Expert Advice team and GearJunkie’s tested boot rankings, against each brand’s own published weight, price, and membrane specifications, and against Danner’s own recrafting program pricing for the resole math above. Where a specific figure, quote, or test result appears in this guide, we named the source in the same sentence rather than presenting it as our own hands-on finding. For more on how we vet products and sources across the site, see our editorial standards page.
We deliberately narrowed a crowded category to six boots, each matched to one specific, real buying question, rather than listing a dozen boots with no clear differentiation between them. Prices reflect what brands and retailers listed at the time of writing; hiking boot pricing shifts with sales fairly often, so confirm current pricing before you buy. Prices are approximate, current as of publication, and change frequently — confirm the latest price with the retailer before buying.
What Actually Matters When You’re Buying One
Waterproofing is a trade-off, not a free upgrade. Every waterproof membrane in this guide — GORE-TEX, KEEN.DRY, B-DRY — traps some heat that a fully breathable trail runner wouldn’t, which is exactly why the water-resistant-only HOKA Mafate Hike above is also the most breathable, cushioned option here. If you hike somewhere genuinely hot and dry more often than genuinely wet, that trade-off is worth weighing honestly rather than defaulting to “waterproof is always better.”

Weight matters more than most first-time buyers expect. The oft-cited rule of thumb among hikers and gear reviewers is that a pound on your feet costs roughly the same energy as five pounds in a pack, because your legs have to lift that weight with every single step. That’s why the half-pound spread between the lightest boot here (the HOKA Mafate Hike) and the heaviest (the Danner Mountain 600 Leaf) is a bigger deal over an eight-mile day than it looks on a shelf.
Break-in time is not optional to plan around. Several boots in this guide — particularly the leather Danner — perform best after a handful of shorter walks before you take them on a real trail. Skipping that step is one of the most common reasons a genuinely good boot ends a hike in blisters instead of praise.
If your next gear purchase is rounding out the rest of a pack rather than your feet, our adventure and extreme sports gear roundup covers trekking poles and hydration packs that pair naturally with any boot above, and our Darn Tough socks review is worth a look before you break in a new pair — the wrong sock undoes a lot of what a good boot does right. For day-trip gear beyond footwear, see our trip-type gear picks for beach, city, and park days. For more picks in this category, browse our full Outdoor Recreation archive.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do hiking boots actually last?
Boot brands typically state a lifespan of 500 to 1,000 miles under normal use, according to Advnture’s guide to hiking boot longevity. Actual mileage depends heavily on terrain, pack weight, and maintenance — a boot used occasionally on gentle trails can last a decade or more, while the same boot used intensively on technical terrain may need replacing within a couple of years.
Is it worth paying more for a resoleable boot?
It depends on how many miles you plan to put on it. Based on our own cost-per-100-miles math above, the Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX’s higher upfront price mostly evens out with cheaper, non-resoleable boots once you factor in a single $100–$140 resole through Danner’s own recrafting program, extending the boot’s usable life to roughly 1,500 miles instead of buying a second pair outright.
Do I need a waterproof boot for day hiking?
Only if you regularly hike in wet conditions, through stream crossings, or in cooler, damp climates. Five of the six boots in this guide use a waterproof membrane (GORE-TEX, KEEN.DRY, or B-DRY); the HOKA Mafate Hike trades full waterproofing for lighter weight and more breathable cushioning, which several reviewers note is the better call for hot, dry terrain.
What’s the difference between a hiking boot and a hiking shoe?
A hiking boot, like the six in this guide, extends above the ankle for added support and protection on uneven terrain, while a hiking shoe stops at or below the ankle for a lighter, more flexible feel. Hikers prone to rolled ankles or carrying heavier loads generally do better in a boot; hikers prioritizing speed and low weight on maintained trails often prefer a shoe.
How much should a good pair of day hiking boots cost?
Based on the prices in this guide, expect to spend $160 to $200 for a genuinely capable waterproof day hiking boot from a reputable brand, or up to roughly $250 for a resoleable, full-leather boot built to last multiple years of regular use.

